Skip to main content

Arbutus Hardwood Floors

Hardwood vs LVP, laminate, carpet, and tile: compare cost, lifespan, and resale for Calgary homes, and find out where each one makes sense.

Most Used Hardwood Flooring Species in Calgary

Written by Arbutus Hardwood Flooring Team | Reviewed by Dave Cunnings, Lead Flooring Specialist

Hardwood vs LVP is the comparison most homeowners start with, and it’s rarely a simple one. Luxury vinyl plank has improved a lot, laminate has its place, and carpet still wins in some rooms. We install hardwood for a living, so we have an obvious bias. But the honest answer is that each floor wins in certain situations, and picking the wrong one costs real money.

Quick answer: Hardwood costs more upfront but lasts the longest, because it can be refinished many times and tends to add resale appeal. LVP is waterproof and budget-friendly, which suits basements, bathrooms, and rentals. Laminate is a lower-cost option for dry rooms. The carpet is softest and warmest but wears the fastest. The best floor depends on the room, your budget, and how long you plan to stay.

Here’s how they compare on cost, durability, moisture, comfort, and resale, with a room-by-room guide at the end.

Hardwood vs LVP, laminate, carpet and tile at a glance

 

Hardwood

LVP

Laminate

Carpet

Tile

Typical installed cost per sq ft

$8 to $22

$4 to $9

$3 to $8

$3 to $8

$8 to $20

Typical lifespan

30+ years with care

10 to 25 years

10 to 25 years

5 to 15 years

30+ years

Can be refinished

Yes, several times

No

No

No

No

Water resistance

Low

High

Low to moderate

Low

High

Feel underfoot

Warm, firm

Slightly soft, can feel hollow

Firm, can feel hollow

Soft, warm

Hard, cold

Resale appeal

Strong

Moderate

Lower

Mixed

Good in wet areas

These are rough Calgary-area ranges, not quotes. Your price depends on the product, the subfloor, and the size of the job. For hardwood pricing in detail, see our hardwood flooring cost guide.

Hardwood vs LVP: the main differences

Hardwood vs LVP the main differences

Cost. LVP is usually much cheaper to buy and install. A typical house can cost thousands less in LVP than in hardwood.

Moisture. This is LVP’s biggest advantage. It handles spills, humidity, and leaks far better than hardwood. That makes it a smart pick for basements, laundry rooms, and bathrooms.

Lifespan and repair. Hardwood can be sanded and refinished several times, so a scratched or worn floor can look new again. LVP can’t be refinished. When the wear layer is damaged, you replace planks or the whole floor. Our guide to hardwood floor refinishing vs replacement explains how that works on wood.

Look and feel. A good LVP can look convincing, but it’s a printed surface over a synthetic core. Real hardwood has natural variation, depth, and a warmth that’s hard to copy. LVP often feels slightly hollow underfoot, especially with thinner products.

Scratches and pets. LVP resists scratches well. Hardwood can scratch, but scratches in the finish can be repaired or refreshed. We cover this in detail in our guide on whether hardwood floors are bad for dogs.

Pro Tip: If you’re considering LVP, ask for the wear layer thickness, measured in mils. For a busy home, a thicker wear layer lasts longer. Cheap, thin products can show wear within a few years.

Hardwood vs laminate

Laminate is a photo layer over a fiberboard core. It’s often the lowest-cost way to get a wood look.

  • Pros: Affordable, scratch resistant, easy to install
  • Cons: Can swell if water gets under it, can’t be refinished, often sounds hollow when walked on

Laminate suits dry, low-traffic rooms on a tight budget. It’s a poor choice for anywhere that might get wet. Hardwood costs more but holds its value better and can be repaired in ways laminate can’t.

Hardwood vs carpet

The carpet is warm, soft, and quiet, and it’s the cheapest per square foot to install in many cases.

  • Pros: Comfortable, good for bedrooms and kids’ rooms, lower upfront cost
  • Cons: Traps dust, dander, and odors, stains easily, wears out in 5 to 15 years

Many Calgary homeowners who buy older houses find hardwood hiding under carpet. If that’s your home, you may be able to restore it instead of replacing it. See our guide on refinishing hardwood floors without sanding to know what’s possible.

Hardwood vs tile

The tile is extremely durable and fully waterproof, which is why it’s the standard for bathrooms and many entryways. It’s also cold and hard underfoot, and heavy to install.

Hardwood is warmer and easier on feet and legs. In wet areas, tile is the better practical choice. In living spaces, hardwood feels more comfortable and adds a different kind of value.

Which floor lasts longest and costs less over time

Upfront price tells only part of the story. A rough way to think about it:

Floor

Install cost

Lifespan

Cost over time

Hardwood

High

30+ years, refinishable

Often lowest per year

LVP

Low to moderate

10 to 25 years

Moderate, replaced when worn

Laminate

Low

10 to 25 years

Moderate

Carpet

Low

5 to 15 years

Highest in the long run

A hardwood floor that lasts 40 years can cost less per year than carpet replaced three times. The catch is that it only works out if you stay long enough or the floor adds value when you sell.

Resale value

Real hardwood is widely seen as a selling point, and listings often highlight it. Quality LVP is accepted and growing in popularity, but it’s not usually viewed the same way. The carpet is mixed, since many buyers see it as something they’ll replace.

Exact results vary by market and home, so we won’t promise numbers. If you plan to sell in the next few years, ask a local real estate agent what buyers in your neighborhood expect.

How Calgary’s climate affects each floor

How Calgary’s climate affects each floor

Hardwood. Calgary’s dry winters can cause seasonal gaps, and humidity swings can lead to cupping if moisture is a problem. Our guides on hardwood floor gaps in Calgary winters and cupping causes explain what’s normal and what isn’t.

LVP. It handles moisture well, but it expands and contracts with temperature changes, so it needs proper expansion gaps. Near big windows with strong sun, it can also heat up and move.

Laminate. It’s the most sensitive to water damage, which matters in basements and near exterior doors in winter.

Carpet. It holds salt, sand, and slush brought in on winter boots, which can be hard to clean fully.

Best flooring by room

Room

Best fit

Why

Living room and dining room

Hardwood

Warmth, look, resale value

Kitchen

Hardwood or LVP

Hardwood if you accept some care, LVP for spills

Bedrooms

Hardwood or carpet

Comfort and warmth

Basement

LVP or engineered hardwood

Moisture risk below grade

Bathroom and laundry

Tile or LVP

Water exposure

Entryway

Tile or hardwood with mats

Winter salt and moisture

Rental or flip

LVP

Cost and durability

Below-grade installs need special care, since moisture is the main risk. The National Wood Flooring Association publishes installation guidelines, and a professional should check your subfloor first. If you want wood in a basement, engineered hardwood is often the option to discuss.

How to decide

  1. Set a budget. Include the full installed price, not just the material.
  2. Think about how long you’ll stay. Longer stays favor hardwood.
  3. List room by room. Don’t use one floor everywhere unless it fits every space.
  4. Check moisture risk. Basements and bathrooms change the answer.
  5. Consider life in the home. Dogs, kids, and traffic matter.
  6. Ask for samples. See them in your light and your room.
  7. Get a local quote. Subfloor conditions can change the price.

Choosing the right floor for your home

Hardwood vs LVP isn’t a contest with one winner. Hardwood is the better long-term investment for main living areas, and LVP is the practical choice for wet spaces and tight budgets. Laminate and carpet have their places, but they wear out sooner and can’t be restored the way wood can.

If you’re leaning toward hardwood and want honest advice on the right product for your home, contact Arbutus Hardwood for a free assessment in Calgary, Airdrie, Cochrane, Okotoks, Chestermere, or nearby. We’ll look at your subfloor, talk through your options, and give you a clear quote. You can also see our hardwood floor installation, custom hardwood flooring, and hardwood floor refinishing services.

Why Wood Species Selection Matters for Calgary Homes

Selecting the right hardwood species is not just a design choice it directly impacts how your flooring performs for years to come. Calgary’s climate creates conditions where wood movement is unavoidable, making it essential to choose a species that can handle these fluctuations without compromising stability.

Each wood type has different levels of density, flexibility, and grain structure. These characteristics determine how resistant the flooring will be to dents, scratches, and seasonal expansion. Homeowners who understand these differences can avoid costly repairs and ensure their flooring maintains both its function and appearance over time.

Durability Differences
Grain Behavior
Moisture Response
When these factors are

carefully considered the result is a floor that not only looks great but also performs reliably in everyday living conditions. Ignoring them often leads to premature wear or dissatisfaction even with high quality materials.

Climate Considerations for Hardwood Flooring in Calgary

Calgary’s dry winters and fluctuating humidity levels make it one of the more challenging environments for hardwood flooring. Wood naturally reacts to moisture, and in a climate where indoor air can become extremely dry, this reaction becomes more noticeable.

Seasonal contraction during winter can create small gaps between planks and summer humidity may cause expansion. These changes are normal, but choosing the right species and installation approach can significantly reduce their impact.

Stable Wood Species
Proper Acclimation
Controlled Indoor Humidity
Proper planning plays a major role in long term performance.

Allowing the wood to acclimate before installation and maintaining consistent indoor humidity levels can prevent many common issues.

Oak Hardwood Flooring

Oak hardwood flooring remains the most popular choice in Calgary due to its exceptional balance of durability, affordability, and design flexibility. It has been widely used for decades and continues to perform reliably in both modern and traditional homes.

One of the key advantages of oak is its strong and visible grain pattern. This natural texture helps conceal everyday wear such as scratches and minor dents, that makes it highly practical for busy households. Unlike smoother woods, oak maintains its appearance even after years of use.

Strong Durability
Visible Grain Texture
Stain Flexibility

Oak is also highly adaptable when it comes to finishing. It accepts stains evenly that allow homeowners to achieve a wide variety of looks without compromising the natural beauty of the wood. Because of this versatility oak remains one of the safest and most recommended choices for Calgary homes.

Maple Hardwood Flooring

Maple hardwood flooring is known for its clean, smooth appearance and subtle grain pattern. It is often chosen for modern interiors where a more uniform and refined look is desired. Compared to oak, maple offers a more contemporary aesthetic that works well in minimalist spaces.

In terms of performance, maple is harder than many other domestic species which makes it resistant to dents and surface wear. However, it is slightly more sensitive to humidity changes, meaning proper installation and environmental control are essential.

High Hardness
Smooth Grain
Modern Appearance

Because of its strength and sleek look, maple is a strong choice for homeowners who want durability without a pronounced grain pattern

Ash Hardwood Flooring

Ash hardwood flooring offers a unique combination of strength and visual character. It is similar to oak in durability but features a more pronounced and dynamic grain pattern, which gives it a distinct appearance.

Its lighter tone makes it ideal for creating bright and open spaces, especially in modern Calgary homes where natural light is a key design element. Ash also provides a level of flexibility that helps it absorb impact better than more rigid species.

Strong Structure
Bold Grain Pattern
Light Color Tones

This combination of durability and visual appeal makes ash a versatile option for homeowners who want something slightly different from traditional oak

Walnut Hardwood Flooring

Walnut hardwood flooring is widely recognized for its rich, dark tones and luxurious finish. It adds depth and warmth to interiors, making it a preferred choice for high end residential spaces.

Although walnut is softer than oak or hickory, its aesthetic value often outweighs this limitation. It performs best in areas with moderate foot traffic, where its appearance can be preserved without excessive wear.

deep color
smooth texture
premium look

For homeowners focused on elegance and design, walnut delivers a level of sophistication that few other species can match. When used in the right setting, it becomes a standout feature in any room

Hickory Hardwood Flooring

Hickory hardwood flooring is one of the toughest domestic options available. Its high density provides excellent resistance to dents, scratches, and heavy foot traffic.

Visually, hickory stands out due to its dramatic color variation and bold grain patterns. This gives it a more rustic and natural look compared to more uniform species like maple.

Extreme Hardness
High Durability
Strong Visual Contrast

Because of its strength hickory is particularly well suited for homes with pets, children, or high daily usage. It is a long term solution for homeowners who prioritize durability above all else.

Cherry Hardwood Flooring

Cherry hardwood flooring is known for its warm, reddish tones that deepen over time. This natural aging process enhances its appearance that gives it a richer and more refined look as the years go by.

While it is softer than many other hardwoods, cherry is valued more for its aesthetic qualities than its durability. It is best suited for areas where foot traffic is limited.

Warm Tones
Smooth Grain
Natural Aging

Cherry is often chosen for formal spaces where elegance and character are more important than heavy duty performance.

Mahogany Wood Floors

Mahogany wood floors are associated with luxury and high end interior design. They feature a fine, even grain and deep color tones that create a sophisticated and polished look.

Mahogany offers moderate hardness and performs well when properly maintained. Its consistent texture gives it a refined appearance that works well in upscale environments.

Rich Color
Fine Grain
Elegant Finish

This species is often selected for statement spaces where visual impact is a priority. It provides a classic, upscale feel that enhances the overall design of a home

Pine Wood Flooring

Pine wood flooring is a softer option that offers a rustic and natural appearance. It features visible knots and grain variations that give it a more casual and lived in look. Because it is softer, pine is more prone to dents and marks. However, many homeowners appreciate this as it adds character over time.

Soft Texture
Rustic Look
Natural Knots

Pine is ideal for farmhouse style or cottage inspired interiors where imperfections contribute to the overall charm of the space.

Ipe Wood Flooring

Ipe wood flooring is an exotic hardwood known for its exceptional durability and resistance to environmental factors. It is significantly harder than most domestic species and performs extremely well under heavy use. Its density also makes it resistant to moisture, insects, and general wear, that makes it a long lasting investment.

Extreme Density
High Resistance
Long Lifespan

Although it is more expensive and harder to install, ipe offers unmatched durability for homeowners looking for a premium solution

Teak Wood Flooring

Teak wood flooring is another premium option valued for its natural oils and moisture resistance. It performs well in environments where humidity changes are common, that features make it a reliable choice. Its warm tones and smooth texture create a welcoming and high end appearance.

Natural Oils and
Moisture Resistance
Premium Finish

Teak is often used in luxury applications where both performance and aesthetics are equally important.

Best Hardwood Flooring Species for High Traffic Areas

Choosing the right species for high traffic areas is essential for maintaining the appearance of your flooring over time. Durability becomes the primary factor in these spaces.

Hickory Hardwood Flooring
Oak Hardwood Flooring
Maple Hardwood Flooring

These species offer the best resistance to wear and are capable of handling daily use without showing significant damage. Selecting one of these options ensures your flooring remains in good condition even in busy households.

Cost Comparison of Different Wood Species

Understanding cost differences helps homeowners make better long term decisions. While initial pricing varies, durability and maintenance also affect overall value.

Budget Friendly: Pine, Ash
Mid Range: Oak, Maple
Premium: Walnut, Cherry
Luxury: Ipe, Teak

Mid range options are the most common because they provide a strong balance between cost and performance. Higher end species are typically chosen for their visual appeal and exclusivity rather than practicality alone.

Common Mistakes When Choosing Hardwood Flooring

Many homeowners overlook key factors when selecting hardwood flooring, which can lead to long term issues. Avoiding these mistakes can save both time and money.

Choosing Based On Looks Only
Ignoring Climate Impact
Overlooking Maintenance Needs
Skipping Professional Installation

Making informed decisions ensures your flooring performs as expected and maintains its appearance over time. Proper planning and expert guidance play a crucial role in achieving the best results

Cost Comparison of Different Wood Species

Understanding cost differences helps homeowners make better long term decisions. While initial pricing varies, durability and maintenance also affect overall value.

Budget Friendly: Pine, Ash
Mid Range: Oak, Maple
Premium: Walnut, Cherry
Luxury: Ipe, Teak

Mid range options are the most common because they provide a strong balance between cost and performance. Higher end species are typically chosen for their visual appeal and exclusivity rather than practicality alone.

 Yes, usually by a wide margin for both material and installation. The difference narrows when you consider that hardwood can last much longer and be refinished.

Hardwood is more often seen as a premium feature. LVP can still help a home show well, especially compared with worn carpet, but it's generally not valued the same way.

Usually not directly. The existing floor typically needs to come out so the hardwood can be fastened or glued to a proper subfloor. A professional should check first.

It can be. It's more stable than solid wood in tricky conditions and gives a real wood surface. The wear layer limits how often it can be refinished, which we explain in our refinishing guide above.

Should you refinish hardwood floors before selling your house?

Should you refinish hardwood floors before selling your house?

Should you refinish hardwood floors before selling your house? Should you refinish hardwood floors before selling your house? See when it’s worth it, what it costs, how long it takes, and what buyers notice in Calgary. Contact Us Most Used Hardwood Flooring Species in Calgary If you’re about to list…

Hardwood flooring installation process: what happens, step by step

Hardwood flooring installation process: what happens, step by step

Hardwood flooring installation process The hardwood flooring installation process explained: prep, acclimation, nail down vs glue down vs floating, timelines, and costs for Calgary homes. Contact Us Most Used Hardwood Flooring Species in Calgary Written by Arbutus Hardwood Flooring Team | Reviewed by Dave Cunnings, Lead Flooring Specialist The hardwood…

Hardwood vs LVP, laminate and carpet: which is best for Calgary homes?

Hardwood vs LVP, laminate and carpet: which is best for Calgary homes?

Hardwood vs LVP, laminate and carpet: which is best for Calgary homes? Hardwood vs LVP, laminate, carpet, and tile: compare cost, lifespan, and resale for Calgary homes, and find out where each one makes sense. Contact Us Most Used Hardwood Flooring Species in Calgary Written by Arbutus Hardwood Flooring Team…

Need Help in Hardwood Floor Installation?

Choosing the right hardwood flooring species is one of the most important steps in creating a durable and visually appealing home. Calgary’s climate requires careful consideration, making it essential to select a species that can handle environmental changes without compromising performance. If you’re planning to install hardwood flooring contact us today to get the best results from your investment.

    Hardwood vs LVP, laminate and carpet: which is best for Calgary homes? 3